Thoughts on Parashat Chukat 5785
Moses and Aaron were probably the greatest Jewish leaders of all times. Both of them commit a sin in our parasha, are punished for it and die. What was their actual sin for which they were to die? Everyone who read or studied this story thinks they know and that it is obvious: they were both told to order the rock, to speak to the rock to yield water, but Moses instead struck the rock with his rod, and struck twice. But I don’t think that this most common explanation reflecting the pshat level – the simple, literal meaning of the story is valid. Why? Let me ask you a question: which of the laws of the Torah Moses and Aaron transgressed? Is there a law to prohibit striking the rock in order to get water from it? None that I know say anything like that. And that’s exactly the common explanation of what was[…]


